By the way, the way I'm organizing this list is exactly the way everything appears in my collection.
Pavement - 
Slanted & Enchanted: Luxe & Reduxe(Streetside Records - Columbia, Mo.)
Pavement - 
Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain(Quonset Hut - Akron, Oh.)
Pavement - 
Terror Twilight(Slackers - Columbia, Mo.)
Pearl Jam - 
Vs.(Gift from mom & dad. The first CD I ever got.)
Pedro the Lion - 
Winners Never Quit(I think it was eBay. Might have been Amazon, though.)
Pedro the Lion - 
Progress(Amazon)
Pedro the Lion -
ControlAchilles Heel(Hastings - Kirskville, Mo.)
Perfect Circle - 
Mer de Noms(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Tom Petty - 
Wildflowers(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers - 
She's the One(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers - 
Anthology: Through the Years(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Pink Floyd -
The Piper at the Gates of DawnUmmagumma(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Pink Floyd - 
Dark Side of the Moon(gift from aunt & uncle)
Pink Floyd -
Wish You Were HereAnimalsThe WallThe Division Bell(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Pink Floyd - 
Pulse(I think, I 
think, I bought this from either Jonathan or Jonas)
Pixies - 
Surfer Rosa(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Pixies - 
Doolittle(BMG)
Pixies - 
Bossanova(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Police - 
Message in a Box: The Complete Recordings(BMG)
Phosphorescent - 
The Weight of Flight(Amazon.....still waiting on their other two in the mail.)
Robert Pollard -
ZoomBubbleFrom a Compound Eye(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Portastatic -
The Nature of SapDe Mel, De Melao(Amazon)
Portastatic -
The Perfect Little DoorSummer of the Shark(Merge Records)
Portastatic - 
Autumn was a Lark(Streetside Records - Columbia, Mo.)
Portastatic - 
Bright Ideas(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.....first CD I bought after moving here)
Postal Service - 
Give Up(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Queens of the Stone Age - 
Songs for the Deaf(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Radiohead -
Pablo HoneyThe Bends(BMG.....actually, 
Pablo Honey might've been at Rineharts)
Radiohead - 
Kid A(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo., special edition bought at Slackers in Columbia, Mo.)
Radiohead -
AmnesiacI Might Be Wrong: Live RecordingsHail to the Thief(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Rage Against the Machine - 
The Battle of Los Angeles(Hmmm, tough one....I can't remember if it was bought at Hastings in Kirksville or Atomic Records in Milwaukee. I just can't remember.)
Rage Against the Machine - 
Renegades(Whizz Records - Columbia, Mo.)
Lou Reed -
New YorkBetween Thought and Expression: The Lou Reed AnthologySongs for Drella (w/ John Cale)
(BMG)
Lou Reed -
Set the Twilight ReelingPerfect Night: Live in London(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
REM -
DocumentGreen(BMG)
REM -
Automatic for the PeopleMonsterNew Adventures in Hi-Fi(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
REM -
RevealIn Time: The Best of REM (1988-2003)(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Rentals -
Return of the RentalsSeven More Minutes(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Replacements - 
Let it Be(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Replacements -
TimPleased to Meet MeDon't Tell a SoulAll Shook Down(BMG)
Replacements - 
All for Nothing, Nothing for All(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Damien Rice - 
O(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Rilo Kiley - 
The Execution of All Things(Saddle Creek)
Rilo Kiley - 
More Adventurous(Amazon)
Rolling Stones -
Beggars BanquetLet it BleedExile on Main St.Sticky FingersGoats Head Soup(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Rushmore Soundtrack
(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.....I'm pretty sure)
Saddle Creek -
50Lagniappe(Saddle Creek....duh)
Sex Pistols - 
Never Mind the Bollocks(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Sigur Ros - 
( )(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Silver Jews - 
Tanglewood Numbers(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Simon and Garfunkel - 
Greatest Hits(gift from aunt & uncle)
Paul Simon - 
s/t(BMG)
Elliott Smith - 
Figure 8(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Elliott Smith - 
From a Basement on the Hill(Streetside Records - Columbia, Mo.)
Smiths - 
Meat is Murder(I think it was at the Quonset Hut in Akron. Might've been at Rineharts in Kirksville, though.)
Smog -
Sewn to the SkyBurning Kingdom'neath the Puke Tree(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Smog - 
Rain on Lens(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Smog - 
A River Ain't Too Much to Love(bought from Wajda via Amazon)
Todd Snider - 
Step Right Up(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Todd Snider - 
Viva Satellite(Quonset Hut - Akron, Oh.)
Son, Ambulance - 
Euphemystic(Amazon)
Son, Ambulance - 
Key(Saddle Creek)
Songs: Ohia -
The GhostProtection Spells(tour-only CDs downloaded from 
here)
Songs: Ohia - 
Didn't it Rain(Amazon)
Songs: Ohia - 
The Magnolia Electric Co.(Slackers - Columbia, Mo.)
Son Volt -
TraceStraightaways(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Son Volt - 
Wide Swing Tremolo(Quonset Hut - Akron, Oh.)
Son Volt - 
Afterglow 61 EP(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Son Volt - 
Okemah and the Melody of Riot(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Sorry About Dresden - 
The Convenience of Indecision(Saddle Creek)
Soul Coughing - 
Irresistible Bliss(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Soul Coughing - 
El Oso(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Spoon - 
A Series of Sneaks(Amazon)
Spoon - 
Love Ways(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Spoon - 
Girls Can Tell(Amazon)
Spoon - 
Kill the Moonlight(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Spoon - 
Gimme Fiction(Merge Records)
Bruce Springsteen - 
The Ghost of Tom Joad(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Stars - 
Set Yourself on Fire(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Sufjan Stevens -
A Sun Came!Enjoy Your Rabbit(Amazon)
Sufjan Stevens - 
Michigan(Amazon)
Sufjan Stevens - 
Seven Swans(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Sufjan Stevens - 
Illinois(Asthmatic Kitty)
Strokes -
Is This itRoom on Fire(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Strokes - 
First Impressions of Earth(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Superchunk - 
s/t(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Superchunk - 
No Pocket for Kitty(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Superchunk -
On the MouthFoolish(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Superchunk -
Incidental Music 1991-95Here's Where the Strings Come in(Amazon)
Superchunk - 
Indoor Living(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Superchunk - 
Come Pick Me Up(Atomic Records - Milwaukee, Wi.)
Superchunk - 
Here's to Shutting Up(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Superchunk - 
Clambakes Vol. 1: Acoustic In-Stores East & West(eBay)
Superchunk - 
Clambakes Vol. 2: A Page of Madness(Merge Records)
Superchunk - 
Cup of Sand(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Superchunk - 
Clambakes Vol. 3: When We Were 10(Merge Records)
Superdrag - 
Regretfully Yours(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Superdrag -
Head Trip in Every KeyIn the Valley of Dying Stars(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Supergrass -
In it for the Moneys/tLife on Other Planets(Hastings - Kirksville, Mo.)
Supergrass - 
Road to Rouen(Plan 9 - Richmond, Va.)
Matthew Sweet - 
Girlfriend(BMG)
Matthew Sweet - 
Altered Beast(Rineharts - Kirksville, Mo.)
Matthew Sweet - 
Son of a Beast(BMG)
Wow, break time! Almost done.